Showing posts with label Le Pen. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Le Pen. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 27, 2010

Le Pen, Chapayev and the Universal Rhyme

At the recent regional elections in France Nicolas Sarkozy's UMP party had a good thrashing from the left and the greens. Where I live Sarkozy isn't very popular. Here is a joke I heard from a French friend.

Sarkozy et Le Pen sont sur un bateau.
Les deux tombent à l'eau.
Qui est sauvé? - La France


Sarkozy and Le Pen were sailing in a boat.
Both fell overboard. Who was saved?
France!

I was struck by the similarity of this simpley-dimpley rhyme to the Russian one I remember since I was in primary school.

Micky-Greggy and Chapay were sailing in the boat.
Micky-Greggy fell overboard and drowned.
Who stayed in the boat?


If you were naive enough to shout: 'Chapay!', you were immediately tickled and pinched as 'Chapay' or 'Chapayev', the name of the legendary red army cossack commander, is phonetically close to the verb 'pinch' in imperative mood.

I told my Russian joke to the French who were, like me, struck by the similarity of the pattern. But it can't be just a coincidence. There must be a source for the rhyme, in French or some other language. Does anyone know what it is?


The Russian novel 'Chapayev' and the 1930s film spurred a  host of jokes with the man as the central character. 
Russian version of this post is here.

I Love Chapayev White Cap
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...